The Chris Stapleton Affair

by Gene Johns

The Country Music Association (CMA) Male Vocalist of the Year award recognizes vocal performance within what the organization considers country music, which increasingly embraces contemporary sounds rather than traditional-country authenticity.

Chris Stapleton won the CMA’s 2026 Male Vocalist of the Year award for the ninth time in twelve years. Good grief, Charlie Brown, no one’s that good! Clearly, the CMA has a love affair with the vocal abilities of Chris Stapleton rather than fidelity to traditional country music.

It is interesting that Chris has dominated that award during a time when pop-country dominates mainstream country music because Stapleton is clearly not pop-country.

I don’t know how to classify Chris Stapleton’s music. It isn’t traditional country, and it certainly isn’t pop-country. Perhaps country blues is the best description. It’s the kind of music you’d expect to hear coming from a dimly lit bar down a back alley in Nashville.

I’m not criticizing Chris Stapleton’s talent. He is an exceptionally talented vocalist in the style of music he performs. What troubles me is that the CMA has repeatedly chosen him over other talented country artists, giving him overwhelming recognition from an organization that is supposed to represent country music.

Let me explain what I mean. Chris Stapleton is to country music what a saxophone is to a symphony orchestra. Both have their place, and both can contribute something special to a musical genre not traditionally associated with their sound. But neither represents the traditional sound of that music, nor should either be considered its standard-bearer.

Stapleton’s dominance of the CMA Male Vocalist of the Year award over the past twelve years has come largely at the expense of artists performing contemporary pop-influenced country music.

Although I’m not a fan of pop-country star Dierks Bentley, he was nominated alongside Stapleton five years in a row. He never won. Stapleton won four of those five years. It seems country music has its own Monopoly game, and Chris owns all the properties while Dierks desperately needs a Get-Out-of-Jail-Free card.

Nestled in with his other pop-country competitors, Blake Shelton and Tim McGraw were notable exceptions, having built their careers with a sound more closely associated with traditional country music. The CMA noticed them much like airline passengers notice flyover country while traveling from coast to coast. They might take a few pictures, but they never land. Blake and Tim were noticed, but neither landed in the winner’s circle.

To their credit, the CMA did give some breathing room to Stapleton’s competition. In 2019 and 2020, Luke Combs took advantage of possible Stapleton fatigue and won the award—two years in a row. I wonder if Chris thought his time had come and gone? Nope! He won the next five out of six years.

But in 2025, something remarkable happened. Traditional country artist Cody Johnson interrupted Stapleton’s second reign over the competition, winning the CMA Male Vocalist of the Year award.

For me, that was the equivalent of baseball’s Amazin’ New York Mets winning the 1969 World Series over the heavily favored Baltimore Orioles.

Cody Johnson seemingly coming out of the blue to dethrone perennial favorite Chris Stapleton isn’t an overnight success story. He has been recording and performing traditional country music for nearly twenty years.

Cody Johnson’s seasoned traditional country sound is the type of country music that should be recognized by the CMA—not Chris Stapleton’s apparently popular bluesy country.

My criticism of Chris Stapleton dominating the CMA Male Vocalist of the Year award (not his fault) for the past twelve years is fundamentally about what the CMA considers country music, rather than whether Stapleton is a talented artist.

Country music isn’t pop music—the most popular music in the land. Country music has a history and established musical traditions that define the genre.

I am genuinely happy for Chris Stapleton and his success. I wish him well. But the CMA’s infidelity to traditional country music is a symptom of what is wrong with today’s country music genre. Popularity has become more important than preserving and promoting authentic country music.

The CMA hasn’t totally ignored true country artists and music. Lainey Wilson, Cody Johnson, and Zach Top are three examples of the CMA recognizing genuine country talent.

One can only imagine a CMA awards ceremony completely dedicated to traditional country music, nominating only real country artists like Zach Top, Lainey Wilson, Cody Johnson, Brandi Behlen, Mo Pitney, Emily Ann Roberts, Ben McPeak, Catie Offerman, and many other talented independent country artists.

Is my criticism of the CMA falling head over heels for Chris Stapleton valid? I’ll let you decide. But my love affair with traditional country music keeps me faithful to the genre I grew up with. I just can’t help defending my kind of country.